Ce n'est pas une crise de liquidité mais une crise de solvabilité.
C'est-à-dire pas une révolte, mais une révolution.
(des petits graphiques pour illustrer:
http://www.contraryinvestor.com/mo.htm)
"Worse than LTCM," by Nouriel Roubini
Economists distinguish between liquidity crises and insolvency/debt
crises. An agent (household, firm, financial corporation, country) can
experience distress either because it is illiquid or because it is
insolvent; of course insolvent agents are – in most cases - also
illiquid, i.e. they cannot roll over their debts. Illiquidity occurs
when the agent is solvent – i.e. it could pay its debts over time as
long as such debts can be refinanced or rolled over - but he/she
experiences a sudden liquidity crisis, i.e. its creditors are
unwilling to roll over or refinance its claims. An insolvent debtor
does not only face a liquidity problem (large amounts of debts coming
to maturity, little stock of liquid reserves and no ability to
refinance). It is also insolvent as it could not pay its claim over
time even if there was no liquidity problem; thus, debt crises are
more severe than illiquidity crises as they imply that the debtor is
insolvent, i.e. bankrupt, and its debt claims will be defaulted and
reduced.....
Today we do not have only a liquidity crisis like in 1998; we also
have a insolvency/debt crisis among a variety of borrowers that
overborrowed excessively during the boom phase of the latest Minsky
credit bubble.
First, you have hundreds of thousands of US households who are
insolvent on their mortgages. And this is not just a subprime problem:
the same reckless lending practices used in subprime – no downpayment,
no verification of income and assets, interest rate only loans,
negative amortization, teaser rates – were used for near prime, Alt-A
loans, hybrid prime ARMs, home equity loans, piggyback loans. More
than 50% of all mortgage originations in 2005 and 2006 had this toxic
waste characteristics. That is why you will have hundreds of thousands
– perhaps over a million - of subprime, near prime and prime borrowers
who will end up in delinquency, default and foreclosure. Lots of
insolvent borrowers.
You also have lots of insolvent mortgage lenders – not just the 60
plus subprime ones who have already gone out of business – but also
plenty of near prime and prime ones. AHM – that went bankrupt last
week – was not exposed mostly to subprime; it was exposed to near
prime and prime. Countrywide has reported sharp losses not only on
subprime lending but also on prime ones. So on top of insolvent
households/mortgage borrowers you have plenty of insolvent mortgage
lenders, subprime and - soon enough - near prime and prime.
You will also have – soon enough – plenty of insolvent home builders.
Many small ones have gone out of business; now it is likely that some
of the larger ones will follow in the next few months. Beazer Homes –
a major home builder - last week had to refute rumors of its impending
insolvency; but so did AHM a few weeks before its insolvency. With
orders for home builders falling 30-40% and cancellation rates above
30% more than a few home builders will become insolvent over the next
year or so.
We also have insolvent hedge funds and other funds exposed to subprime
and other mortgages. A few – at Bear Stearns, in Australia, in
Germany, in France – have already gone bankrupt or are near bankrupt.
You can be sure that with at least of $100 billion of subprime alone
losses – and most losses are still hidden given the reckless practice
of mark-to-model rather than mark-to-market - many more will go belly
up. In the meanwhile the CDO, CLO and LBO market have completed closed
down - a “constipated owl” where “absolutely nothing moves” the way
Bill Gross of Pimco put it. This is for now a liquidity crisis in
these credit markets; but credit events will occur given that the
underlying problem was not of of liquidity but rather one of
insolvency: if you take a bunch of to-be-defaulted subprime and near
prime mortgages and you repackage them into RMBS and then these RMBS
are repackaged into various tranches of CDOs, the rating agencies may
be using magic voodoo to turn those junk BBB- mortgages into AAA
tranches of CDOs; but this is only voodoo as the underlying assets are
going to be defaulted on.....